Reviews
Michael Liebman
13 January 2025
18 days ago
Stopped on my way back to Northern NY near Canadian border. Great choices. Brought home cannolis, cookies and black and whites... would have loved to take mo...
Read more
Elena Albanese
13 January 2025
18 days ago
I can't say enough great things about this bakery—it's been my family's go-to since I was a little girl! The chocolate sprinkle ring cake has been a staple at e...
Read more
jandychoe
11 December 2024
2 months ago
SO GOOD! You walk in there and you dont expect much except you are surprised because its AMAZING! and this is from a picky pastry eater ha. Walked in thanksgivi...
Read more
Paul Freyder
29 November 2024
2 months ago
Nice people. Great pastries. Good prices.
Annette Spreizer
25 November 2024
2 months ago
Christa Lucarelli
07 October 2024
4 months ago
I needed a cake for a family celebration and knew Mike would make the most delicious cake. The chocolate cake with 1/2 cannoli filling and 1/2 napoleon custard...
Read more
Michelle D'Orio
27 September 2024
4 months ago
Abigail Soper
01 September 2024
5 months ago
christina
16 June 2024
7 months ago
great bakery. staff always a pleasure
Brian D
03 June 2024
8 months ago
Went to Merritt Bakery for the first time to order a birthday cake and they were an absolute pleasure through the whole process. Friendly, helpful, outstanding...
Read more
Stephen
26 May 2024
8 months ago
✨Yummy ✨ 🤤🍪🎂🍰
Jessica Lynn
12 May 2024
9 months ago
my favorite bakery!
Angela Calma
31 March 2024
10 months ago
I love this bakery, the staff is friendly and the baked goods are delicious!
Jamel Ferguson
02 March 2024
a year ago
Jason Hoenig
19 February 2024
a year ago
Got 2 loaves of Italian bread with seeds, they were ok. Girl that waited on me was very nice.
Maria Bethune
15 February 2024
a year ago
Perfect Barbie cake for my 4 year old! The cake was gorgeous and delicious. Moist and perfectly layered. I’ve been using this bakery for years and am always blo...
Read more
Jason Rowland
05 February 2024
a year ago
We went in last minute before a family dinner and the gentleman behind the counter was kind and very generous. We got 2 lobster tails, Napoleon, rainbow cookies...
Read more
Stephanieandjoseph Farco
28 January 2024
a year ago
We called Mike in a panic because another bakery did not have our sons bday cake ready ( we had ordered it a week ahead of time). Well Mike saved the day!!! We ...
Read more
Edward Hernandez
17 January 2024
a year ago
Leslie Kao
14 January 2024
a year ago
My favorite was their Linzor tart cookie- cute heart and perfect cookie texture and perfect raspberry jelly.
Kimberly
02 December 2023
a year ago
The cookies and bread are really good!
Lace and green nut cookies are so 😋😋🤤🤤 no wonder during holidays people order all over the US!
April Crogan
15 November 2023
a year ago
I needed a spur of the moment gift for a friend. I ordered a dozen whoopie pies and they were delivered within the hour. My friend's office is 3 miles away. Mi...
Read more
Barbara Schaefer
26 October 2023
a year ago
Spectacular. Just about the best baked goods every. Worth the trip. Every single item is wonderful. The whoopie pie is the GOAT.
Christine Maddox
25 October 2023
a year ago
The best bakery on Long Island. Everything I’ve tried is delicious and fresh. My favorites are the rainbow cookies, the pumpernickel loaf, black and white cooki...
Read more
Jays
23 October 2023
a year ago
Excellent mud pie. Cakes & pastries are tasty & very affordable unlike many exorbitantly pricey other bakeries.
Couldn't locate it easily because the main sign...
Read more
Brian Snyder
15 October 2023
a year ago
Best long time family owned bakery in the neighborhood and pretty much anywhere.
KEVIN OWENS
15 October 2023
a year ago
Mary Badalamente
05 October 2023
a year ago
I met with Mike the baker, about a simple wedding cake I needed for our daughter's church wedding celebration. Told him exactly what we wanted, and boy he did n...
Read more
Review Drew
21 September 2023
a year ago
I can’t give Mike and his team enough praise. It’s a great, delicious bakery. It may not look like much from the outside but every single time I’ve gone, Mike...
Read more
Raul Ballestas
07 August 2023
a year ago
Great whoopee pie, black and white cookies. My wife's cake looked incredible!!! They are worth the trip. Please support a good local business. They are so cordi...
Read more
Brody brody
30 July 2023
2 years ago
Awesome bakery . They have all the basics and then they have these mini apple turnovers that are really great and specialty items like pizza dough or custom cak...
Read more
Luciene B
26 June 2023
2 years ago
I ordered a special cake for a 90th & 60th surprise Birthday party from Merritt Bakery
Mike was very helpful and delivered a fantastic cake. it was Beautiful a...
Read more
camille laudisio
25 June 2023
2 years ago
This bakery is 30 minutes from my home and I will only go there. The place is immaculate and everything in there is always fresh and delicious. Their crumb buns...
Read more
Randy Katakofsky
20 May 2023
2 years ago
Just had a fundraiser and used Mike from the bakery for some after dinner sweetness. How can you go wrong with fluffy moist crumb cake. When you’re in there, gr...
Read more
Aarti Abnave
28 March 2023
2 years ago
OMG!!! I bought a carrot cake for a small celebration and the cake is mind blowing.
So rich, creamy and nutty it just can’t get better. The lady was super sweet...
Read more
Christopher Kelly
23 March 2023
2 years ago
Michael Hoffman
15 February 2023
2 years ago
Such a wonderful treat. I never realized it was there but now I am glad is it.
Rob
13 February 2023
2 years ago
For the 1st time, because I wanted to find a new go-to establishment, and I read other reviewer comments, I went to Merritt Bakery yesterday after pre-ordering ...
Read more
I jafri
29 January 2023
2 years ago
Very inexpensive!
Ali Cattt
04 October 2022
2 years ago
Merritt Bakery is a hidden gem in the community. Mike the baker...coolest guy ever and makes the most delicious confections! Yesterday was my Birthday and my ...
Read more
Ramon Luna
13 August 2022
2 years ago
Meagan Moore
15 July 2022
3 years ago
Ordered a cake for my co-worker's birthday. It was delivered on time and with care. I really appreciate the personal calls from the owner making sure all detail...
Read more
Mike Lamb
30 June 2022
3 years ago
Tom Z
17 April 2022
3 years ago
katherinne duenas
25 January 2022
3 years ago
Scott Friszell
01 January 2022
3 years ago
It is the best
Shaina Zebrowski
21 November 2021
3 years ago
We ordered my in-laws anniversary cake from Merritts Bakery. It was delicious and beautifully done for a great price. Highly recommend!
Mary Palermo
10 November 2021
3 years ago
My new favorite bakery! The cookies are delicious and the owner was so welcoming. This will be the place I order from.
bob rosen
29 October 2021
3 years ago
Nice local bakery , near LiDL store in Farmingdale . Has been there at least 20 years I know of . Coffee for purchase available for those who drink it , last t...
Read more
Karen Adams
09 October 2021
3 years ago
We ordered a gift basket of cupcakes and cookies to be delivered to a friend in Massapequa for her 95th birthday. We are in Brisbane, Australia and tried a numb...
Read more
Geetha Reddy
07 June 2021
4 years ago
We have ordered cake which is in tree log shape by showing a picture. Mike, the baker has done a wonderful job on that. Immediately when I show the picture of t...
Read more
Henry
25 May 2021
4 years ago
Small bakery with small assortment of pastries. But positively delicious.
Madeline Morales
25 May 2021
4 years ago
Ann Marie Doering
07 May 2021
4 years ago
Delicious gluten free cupcakes and chocolate chip cookies. They can make any cake gf, I am so excited. The best part is that they are not crazy expensive lik...
Read more
Holly Christ
06 May 2021
4 years ago
The best no sugar added items we have ever had ! Just wish they had more of a selection of them ! Can’t wait to go back
Karee Anderson
05 May 2021
4 years ago
Mike accommodated a late evening delivery (after he was home from work, came back to pick up the cake to deliver it!) without question, making my sister's birth...
Read more
Louis Buono
10 April 2021
4 years ago
What a wonderful bakery. Delicious cakes, doughnuts, pastry, bread. I recommend the onion rolls and the crumb cake the staff is very pleasant and helpful.
Updat...
Read more
Randy Davis
19 January 2021
4 years ago
Emma Meaghan
04 December 2020
4 years ago
Simply superb. I ordered special customized cake form Merritt bakery and it was beyond the limit, totally fresh baked, up to expatiations and marvelous in shape...
Read more
Johanna Keep
02 December 2020
4 years ago
Just ordered (and ate!!) the best cassata cake for my sister's 60th birthday!!! Merritt Bakery never disappoints!!!
Joseph Ferrarese
19 October 2020
4 years ago
John Bittlingmeyer
11 October 2020
4 years ago
My boss retired after 43 yes of service, we had a small get together for him and ordered the cake from mike and the staff at Merritt bakery.
Words can't describ...
Read more
Kat Brown
10 July 2020
5 years ago
I ordered a cake for my Aunt to be delivered to her home. I ordered a Chocolate cake, I received a photo of it it was awesome. The person who took my order gav...
Read more
Maura Wheeler
03 February 2020
5 years ago
I live out of state and needed nine trays of cookies delivered to a business in the area. Mike was extremely helpful, kind, and made the entire process easier t...
Read more
bob mott
20 November 2019
5 years ago
John Dounias
02 November 2019
5 years ago
Ken Schreiber
22 July 2018
7 years ago
Merritt bakery makes the best cake and cookies.
Pastries are amazing.
I ordered an Elmo cake for kids birthday party.
Everyone loved it and was all gone.
John Ritchie
09 June 2018
7 years ago
Whoopie Pies!!!
Rich P
07 December 2017
7 years ago
Merritt Bakery is a small bakery with a nice selection of baked goods. Quality is excellent and price's are reasonable. The only downside is selection is small ...
Read more
John Scudder
31 July 2017
8 years ago
Can't wait to visit this bakery again when I get back to NY on holiday. Probably September 5 or 6
Kathy Romano
29 March 2017
8 years ago
The place is very sad 5o be nuce
Mark Harrod
06 November 2013
11 years ago
One of the best things in the city. I like it in here, my mother introduced this place to me and I am really thankful that I know a place that can provide quali...
Read more